Evaluation

Grading Rubric

A = Excellent 18 - 20 B = Good 15 - 17 C = Average 12 - 14 D = Not Complete <12 (resubmit)

	Beginning 1	Developing 2	Accomplished 3	Exemplary 4
Role Responsibility	Presents a basic job description.	Presents a basic job description as it relates to the energy issue.	Presents a basic job description & takes a definitive stand, for or against as it relates to the energy issue.	Incorporates the job description, energy issue and position reflecting the highest level of performance.
Research Questions 2-7 for your job title	Answered questions 2 & 3 Description of how power plants produce electricity via oil & coal.	Answered previous questions and 4 & 5 Description of pollutants and related technologies that deal with these pollutants.	Answered previous questions & 6 Offers identifiable, research- based reasons reflecting the highest level of performance.	Answered previous questions & 7 Offers identifiable, research- based reasons reflecting the highest level of performance.
PowerPoint Content	Slides contain the minimum amount of information required.	The roles were presented on a generic level.	Research supports the position of each role reflecting mastery of performance.	The research, slide content & position reflect a persuasive integration of ideas at the highest level of performance.
PowerPoint Teamwork	Each piece is separate and not integrated.	Collaboration is evident.	Each team member integrated research and supported a position.	Presentation was cohesive & comprehensive.
Individual Summary Paragraph	Attempts to summarize but has no clear position.	Lists facts to support a position.	Connects the research with evidence that supports a position reflecting a mastery of performance.	Takes a personal stand that synthesizes research, technology & the human perspective.